Frankly my dear, I do give a damn!!
When it comes to fighting for justice, I will personally stand up and be counted, even when the case is rather controversial. After all. it’s easy to have compassion for someone you love. It’s much more challenging when someone has a few prickles…or a past. Yet, sometimes our journey takes us down that road and we are forced to argue the points backwards and forwards inside our heads until we can make sense of it all and hopefully judgement turns to love.
I don’t know if the imminent execution of two convicted Australian drug smugglers in Indonesia has made International news. However, as citizens of the world, this case affects each and every one of us who believe in the sanctity and importance of justice and the capacity for humanity to change and redeem itself.
We are all called to stand up and fight.
The case I am referring to is the imminent execution of two convicted Australian drug smugglers in Indonesia: Myuran Sukumaran and Andrew Chan, who were part of the notorious Bali Nine. Since their conviction, these men have completely turned their lives around and deserve a second chance. I’m not saying that they shouldn’t be punished. Just that they don’t deserve to die.
My justification for clemency lies in the science of brain plasticity or neuroplasticity. If you know anything at all about brain plasticity, you will know and understand that these men have changed the very physical structures of their brains through rehabilitation and are no longer who they were. That they are, indeed, very different men. After all, if you have a different brain, how can you possibly be the same?
Victorian Supreme Court Justice Lex Lasry , summed this up well when he addressed the Melbourne vigil held on 18th February, 2014. Lasry had been involved in the case of Van Nguyen, the Melbourne man who was executed for drug trafficking in Singapore in 2005. Lasry said that he has visited Chan and Sukumaran in jail in Bali several times and was in no doubt the pair had redeemed themselves.
“The reality is that if Indonesia go ahead and execute these two men, they’ll be killing an artist and a church pastor,” he said.
“The drug traffickers have gone. The drug traffickers left in 2005. “4.
About Brain Plasticity
Neuroplasticity, also known as brain plasticity “refers to changes in neural pathways and synapses due to changes in behaviour, environment, neural processes, thinking, emotions, as well as changes resulting from bodily injury. Neuroplasticity has replaced the formerly-held position that the brain is a physiologically static organ, and explores how – and in which ways – the brain changes throughout life.”
In The Brain Which Changes Itself, Norman Doidge M.D. a psychiatrist and researcher set out to investigate neuroplasticity. “He writes that the brain can change itself. It is a plastic, living organ that can actually change its own structure and function, even into old age. Arguably the most important breakthrough in neuroscience since scientists first sketched out the brain’s basic anatomy, this revolutionary discovery, called neuroplasticity, promises to overthrow the centuries-old notion that the brain is fixed and unchanging. The brain is not, as was thought, like a machine, or “hardwired” like a computer. Neuroplasticity not only gives hope to those with mental limitations, or what was thought to be incurable brain damage, but expands our understanding of the healthy brain and the resilience of human nature”. http://www.normandoidge.com/?page_id=1259
This brain plasticity isn’t just something for the laboratory or people experiencing chronic medical conditions or disability. It affects us all and is a more “scientific” explanation for what we have always known: “Use it or lose it!!”
To get an idea of how brain plasticity works, picture an old fashioned telephone exchange with all those cables plugged in. Our brain is built of these cables. So for example if we keep getting angry, those anger pathways will keep getting bigger and bigger just like exercising a muscle. Moreover, the bigger these pathways become, the angrier we will become unless we take action.
Conversely, each and every time we appease our anger and breathe deep, count to three whatever it takes, those neuropathways shrink and actually disappear. These are actual, physical changes in the structure of our brains. The brain map is different.
I have experienced these changes myself after undergoing brain surgery to treat hydrocephalus. I have experienced many changes but probably the most surprising is that I can actually play the violin and I now play in an ensemble. That takes some pretty complex brain and physical developments, which I never thought possible. I only took the violin up to help my daughter.
My argument is that through rehabilitation, Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran have demonstrated that through such brain plasticity, they are no longer the men they were.
Therefore, as an exceptional case and while not dismissing the severity of their crime, these new men deserve a compassionate response…jail not execution!
This quote from US President John F. Kennedy sums it up well:
“The problems of the world cannot possibly be solved by skeptics or cynics whose horizons are limited by the obvious realities. We need men who can dream of things that never were.”
Background to the Bali Nine
Myuran Sukumaran and Andrew Chan were the ring leaders of a group of Australian drug traffickers known as “The Bali Nine”. On 17 April 2005, the Bali Nine were arrested for planning to smuggle 8.3 kg (18 lb) of heroin valued at about A$4 million from Indonesia to Australia. These men were no angels and heroin, as we know, is a hard core drug which destroys lives. Authorities must do whatever it takes to get heroin off the streets. While people do dispute the death penalty, they are not advocating a more relaxed after to stopping the trade of heroin.
Going back to the time of their arrest, I didn’t have any sympathy for the Bali 9. Due to the very publicised case of alleged drug trafficker, Australian Shapelle Corby, the severity of Indonesia’s drug laws had been front page news for some time. I might not agree with the death penalty but Indonesia’s tough anti-drug laws most definitely weren’t a secret.
Australian Shapelle Corby had been arrested in Indonesia on 8 October 2004 when she was found to have 4.2 kg (9.3 lb) of cannabis in a double plastic vacuum-sealed bag in her unlocked bodyboard bag. Corby was convicted on 27 May 2005 and sentenced to 20 years in prison by the Denpasar District Court and imprisoned in Kerobokan Prison. To this day, Shapelle maintains her innocence and there have been numerous theories about how the cannabis got into her body board bag. Her case became a “cause celeb” and during that media frenzy, the severity of Indonesia’s drug laws was made very, very clear.
From where I was sitting in front of the TV, you’d have to be a complete idiot or have a serious death wish to even consider smuggling drugs in or out of Indonesia. I know people talked about making their luggage more secure after Shapelle’s arrest. Indeed, I’d even be checking the paperwork on my prescriptions before heading to Indonesia…especially given the amount of pills I take in a week. They could easily be perceived as trafficking quantities!
Those were the sorts of precautions your average Australian traveler was taking when the Bali 9 were arrested. Nobody wanted to be another Shapelle Corby and we were leaving absolutely nothing to chance. The consequences were just too great.
Given the historical context, the Bali 9 did come across as a bunch of idiots who had earned themselves what’s known as the Darwin Award: http://www.darwinawards.com/ After all, they didn’t need to be Einstein or have some kind of mystical crystal ball to know what they were getting themselves into. They just needed to turn on their TV. Shapelle Corby’s face was everywhere. Remember: Shapelle Corby was arrested on the 8th October 2004 and on the 27 May 2005 she was convicted and sentenced to 20 years in prison. The Bali Nine was arrested On 17 April 2005, the Bali Nine were arrested right in the middle of Shapelle’s trial. You do have to wonder what they were thinking and if they were even thinking at all and certainly you would never expect these men to amount to anything much at all!!
That was then. This is now.
Fast-forwarding nine years, Myuran Sukumaran and Andrew Chan are changed men and are inspiring other prisoners and leading exemplary lives. These are not the same men who were convicted back in 2006. Their names might be the same and they are older versions of themselves but in terms of their soul, spirit, character and no doubt even the neurofibres in their brains, they are not who they were. Therefore, executing these men would be a great travesty of justice.
Victorian Supreme Court Justice Lex Lasry has long campaigned against the death penalty and was involved in the case of Van Nguyen, the Melbourne man who was executed for drug trafficking in Singapore in 2005.
Julie Bishop, Australian Minister for Foreign Affairs outlined how much the men had changed when she addressed Federal Parliament on 12th February, 2014:
“Both men are deeply, sincerely remorseful for their actions. Both men have made extraordinary efforts to rehabilitate.
Andrew and Myuran are the model of what penal systems the world over long to achieve.
Successive Governors of Kerobokan Prison in Bali – whose prison has given Andrew and Myuran the opportunity to reflect and change – have testified to their remarkable transformation.
A decade on from their crimes, Andrew and Myuran are changed men. They are deeply committed to a new path.
Both men are paying their debt to society. With dedication and unwavering commitment, they are improving and enriching the lives of their fellow prisoners.
Andrew has completed a theology degree in prison. As a pastor, he now provides religious counselling and guidance to fellow inmates. On the day he received the President’s rejection of his clemency application, Andrew’s Australian lawyer Julian McMahon said he was nowhere to be found, for even at this moment of undeniable personal anguish, Andrew had taken time out to comfort a fellow inmate who was seriously ill.
Myuran – referred to by many as the ‘gentle giant’ – has nearly completed a fine arts degree in jail. He has had the opportunity to become an accomplished artist; his raw talent recognised and fostered by his friend and mentor, renowned artist Ben Quilty.
In prison, Andrew and Myuran sought permission from prison authorities and began an array of courses to benefit fellow inmates, and to prepare them for their return to society.
They have led extensive and varied arts, cultural and vocational courses. Some of their courses are aimed directly at drug addicts, equipping them with the skills to beat their addiction, saving their lives and giving them real prospects in the future.
Andrew and Myuran have raised money for fellow inmates’ medical procedures; for victims of Typhoon Haiyan; for Indonesia National Day festivities.
Indeed, such is the profound effect of Andrew and Myuran’s inspiring humility and service, their fellow prisoners have come forward to lend support, even offering to take their place in execution to President Widodo…
Their remarkable rehabilitation, and the circumstances of their arrest, has prompted five successive Australian Prime Ministers to make representations in their name. ”
What Brain Plasticity Means For Chan & Sukumaran. Why Spare These Men?
If somebody completely turns their life around and becomes an entirely new and different person on the inside, should they still be judged and sentenced to death because of crimes they committed in the past? Although they have the same name and DNA, they are a different person and things become very problematic.
Would justice truly be served and can we as a global community just stand back in good conscience and do nothing to spare these men? Or, do we both as a society and as individuals need to do whatever it takes to prevent such a tragic and unjust loss of life?
The answer is a resounding “yes”!! After all, two wrongs have never made a right!!
Although I have never met these men and I certainly don’t support the use or sale of such drugs, there is such resounding evidence that these men have significantly and are now dramatically improving the lives of those around them as well, rehabilitating and educating other prisoners much more effectively than other methods.
“Power is of two kinds. One is obtained by the fear of punishment and the other by acts of love. Power based on love is a thousand times more effective and permanent then the one derived from fear of punishment.”
Deputy Opposition Leader Tanya Plibersek, whose husband was charged and convicted of a similar crime to Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran, spoke out in Parliament saying: “criminals can be redeemed – my husband is proof.”
She adds that the laws which underpin the executing these men is the basic “eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth” law that has influenced the Old Testament and earlier legal codes in countries around the world. But that’s 3,700 years ago. We’ve moved on a great deal from an eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth”. http://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-02-12/plibersek-these-men-deserve-restorative-justice-not-execution/6088334.
I also thought it was interesting that at last night’s vigil, emotional statements were read from the pair, which acknowledged their original stupidity, saying that the “compassion and kindness from people forgiving our stupidity” has made them feel “truly blessed” 4″
Their Last Words
Andrew Chan: “Thoughts from the Edge
“Thank you Jesus that you give me the strength and courage that I need to stand strong and to trust in you when the waters arise.”
“I thank you Jesus that you never give up on me and that your faithfulness is what helps me striving forward. I thank you for all the family and friends you surround me with in life and how your love pours out from them.”
“The Lord is revealing to me through this scripture is about how he’ll fight the battles for us and that we won’t be defeated if he goes ahead of us… The truth is God is remind us that when all seems helpless and you feel as though the enemies army surrounds you, God is telling us to stand still, take up our battle stance but do not move.”
Myuran Sukumaran – Thoughts from the edge
“When you are young you think money is the only way to get happiness … after being here for eight years you realize it is not.”
“After being in prison for eight years I only realized when it comes when it comes to drugs nobody gets rich – there are a few people – most get caught and end up in places like this and that’s the lesson.”
“I want to become a better person and I want to help everybody else become a better person as well. It is like a vehicle for everybody to travel in to better themselves.”
Last Words or a New Beginning…
Time is running out and I don’t know what any of us can do at this late hour. I understand that over 30,000 Australians have written to the Indonesian Attorney General pleading for mercy and many many people have spoken publically. Last night, a vigil was being held in Sydney to pray for the men and their families and this was just one of many. I can sense a collective heartache if these efforts fail and these two young men are put to death.
Andrew Chan and Myuran Sukumaran are in my heartfelt prayers.
“And the peace of God, which passeth all understanding, shall keep your hearts and minds through Christ Jesus”.
*Please reblog this post and spread the word. It now looks like the lives of these men rest on divine intervention and people power.
As the saying goes: “Never give up”!!!
Love & Blessings,
 · Pascual-Leone A., Amedi A., Fregni F., Merabet L. B. (2005). “The plastic human brain cortex”. Annual Review of Neuroscience 28: 377–401. doi:10.1146/annurev.neuro.27.070203.144216.
 Parliamentary motion: Chan and Sukumaran, Address to House of Representatives Speech, E&OE, Parliament House, Canberra,12 February 2015.
I apologise for any breaches of copyright regarding the images used in this post. I am merely trying to support their cause.
I do believe the brain can change, no doubt. I also don’t agree with the sentence, per se. Did I miss if they had killed anyone? Or just drug trafficking? Anyway. My point would be, how do you punish the ‘old mind’? Sadly, it still inhabits the same body. Until society finds a better way to punish criminals or hey, even better, just get rid of crime altogether! We’ll be punishing ‘innocent’ brains until we figure out a better way.
Btw, I’ve not heard about it in US, however, I live under a rock and don’t follow current events 😉
I am interested to see what sort of feedback I receive on this post. I know what I’m putting together here is rather left field for most people. I have seen footage of these pathways being created under the microscope and also seen the synapses disappear. For me this is a wonderful concept because a whole swag of my bad habits could seemingly be changed. I wasn’t set in stone. I used to find listening to music annoying because I was overly sensitive to noise and after playing the violin, this has really improved. Despite having had brain surgery, I can play my violin in an ensemble where I have an ear out listening to the other part to make sure I’m on track. I would never have thought I could pull that off. I’ve never been good at dividing my attention. While applying the principles of brain plasticity to medical rehabilitation is a wonderful, warm fuzzy kind of thing applying the very same principles to the rehabilitation of criminals is much more complex.
Getting back to the specifics of the Bali Nine. They didn’t kill anyone. The Australian Federal Police were tipped off I think by one of the fathers of the Bali Nine and instead of waiting until they had arrived in Australia, they were arrested in Indonesia where they were under much more severe Indonesian law.
I think pretty much the Australian Government is thinking that they will spend their lives or at least a very long time in prison if they do receive clemency. No one is disputing the severity of their crime and the need for a serious punishment, even though they have rehabilitated.
I guess that also raises the whole point of our penal system. is it just about punishment or is it also about reform and wherever possible re-educating the prisoner so they can make a valuable contribution to society? Ideally, I would hope to do the latter.
Pingback: Compassion Fatigue: A Light Bulb Moment! | beyondtheflow
Wow Rowena. How current is this? I don’t have cable so if it made national news it wasn’t on a channel that I have. I’ve never understood why a prisoner is kept around so long if they are going to be executed. It is ashame to see them executed after seem “rehabilitated”. I’m not going to say that there isn’t anyone who deserves death because there are crimimals who have been imprisoned (like serial killers etc) that I am sure families would want put to death. So it seems sterotypical that drug traffickers would have also been killers but this doesn’t say and though I’m not up on laws and legislation I did think that people were only given death penalties when they’ve killed someone. This was a very interesting post. I’d love to see it made into a movie or a book to grasp everything that happened over that period of time. It would be interesting to see.
Kenya, this situation is current and the Australian government, lawyers and community are currently trying to save them. There is some very, very last ditch appeal going ahead next week but it’s not looking good. LIke you, I think they have left it too late to execute these men now that they have reformed. It is an interesting story to follow and if you Google Bali Nine I’m sure you’ll get updates. I provided a bit of a historical perspective here because I know most of my visitors come from overseas and wuldn’t know the story. I don’t think it is getting much coverage but I wouldn’t know xx Rowena
Thanks for the reply. I’m going to follow the story. Wow.
Pingback: Brain Plasticity & Saving Two Australians o...
Pingback: N is for Neuroplasticity: Changing Your Life. | beyondtheflow
Pingback: Punishment Versus Justice: Two Australians Executed in Indonesia. | beyondtheflow