B: Botticelli…A-Z Challenge.

This year my theme for the A-Z Challenge is Letters to Dead Artists. Yesterday’s artist was A: Alexandros of Antioch who reputedly sculpted the famous Venus de Milo.

Today, I am writing to Sandro Botticelli (c. 1445 – May 17, 1510), an Italian painter of the Early Renaissance. He belonged to the Florentine School under the patronage of Lorenzo de’ Medici.

The piece of music I have chosen to represent Botticelli is: O Fortuna – Carmina Burana

I was introduced to Botticelli’s works in 1992 when I visited Florence’s Uffizi Gallery, as a 23 year old Australian backpacking through Europe. That was when I first saw The Birth of Venus. I was awestruck, and loved it enough to buy a print and cart it all the way back to Australia in my very overweight backpack. That says a lot!

In addition to admiring his achievements as an artist, this letter also addresses Botticelli’s role and possible participation in the Bonfire of the Vanities.  On the 7th February 1497, supporters of the Dominican friar Girolamo Savonarola collected and publicly burned thousands of objects such as cosmetics, art, and books in Florence, Italy, on the Mardi Gras festival. It is believed that Botticelli may have added some of his works to the pyre. It is hard to comprehend what went up in those flames, but there’s no doubt that priceless works of art and other cultural treasures were destroyed.

Sandro_Botticelli_083

Probable self-portrait of Botticelli, in his Adoration of the Magi (1475)

Letter to Sandro Botticelli

Dear Botticelli,

How are you? I expect that’s a rather rhetorical question these days. I was only being polite, but if you feel like responding in some way, I’d only be too happy to hear from you. Sometimes, the walls between heaven and earth aren’t quite what they seem, and people might even wander in and out. I don’t know. They’ve never spoken to me.

Anyway, I am writing to you to ask you a question. While that might seem simple enough, it’s much easier to ask a lot of questions, than it is to narrow it down to one, especially when I’m writing to such a monumentally great artist like yourself.

Botticelli, I first came across your paintings in the Summer of 1992 when I spent three days in Florence. It was stinking hot and I still remember the relief of an icy cold, real Italian gelato. Although I’d already visited The Louvre in Paris which had blown my mind, going to the Uffizzi Gallery, also felt like all my senses were being energized at once. I still remember seeing The Birth of Venus on the wall with its fairytale beauty and Venus standing in the shell. It was mesmerizing. Yet, it didn’t end there. Like a glutton at a sumptuous feast, there was more, including Primavera (1470s or early 1480s) and Pallas and the Centaur (1482-1483). I had just had my heart broken and I knew that anguish screaming through the centaur’s eyes. I also remember being swept away by your more religious works, although I can’t remember them by name.I don’t know how to describe that enormity of feeling. The best I can do, is compare it to falling in love…all consuming, passionate, divine.

Primavera

Primavera, Sandro Botticelli, Uffizi Gallery.

I don’t know whether it’s right to pull apart those feelings, or to try to work out why. Or, whether I should be pulling apart and analysing the life out of such a masterpiece. Or, whether it is better to simply leave it be as pure, unadulterated  awe and wonder.

One thing’s for sure. I didn’t want to hear this magnificent reflection of something in my soul denigrated by my future boyfriend as: “the naked woman standing in a shell”. What? How could he? Philistine! Despite being a Christian, I didn’t denigrate it because it was “pagan” either. How could I let ideology or doctrine come between me and something of such beauty and spirit?

This brings me to the Bonfire of the Vanities and my question.

How did you allow yourself to be swept away by Girolama Savonarola? How could you even be a bystander to the Bonfire of the Vanities on February 7, 1497 in Piazza del Signoria, Florence? Indeed, it’s even been suggested that you even added some of your own works to the pyre. I’m sorry if I’m coming on a bit too strong, but I can’t understand how an artist like you could stand by and do nothing. Let it happen. Or, even worse, join in and be a part of it.

That’s not to judge you, Sir. I didn’t mean to get so fired up. However, it terrifies me that The Birth of Venus and your other so-called “pagan works” could have been, in effect, burned at the stake, and humanity robbed. Indeed, I shudder at all the artworks and treasures that were lost. No doubt, you do too.

Strangely, I only found out about the Bonfire of the Vanities last night. Of course, you can’t know every piece of history. Yet, as a writer, a photographer, a creative who fears the mighty forces of fire and flood, I should have known about that. Marked it on my calendar every year to remember how doctrine and politics can destroy the creative spirit and its progeny.

I wonder how you feel about all that now. Is there regret? Perhaps, but I hope you’re primarily proud of how your works have been revered and considered among the greatest paintings of all time. You’re a genius!

Indeed, I wish I could meet you and not just sit down for a coffee, but to see you paint. Hear you speak. What inspired you? How can a 21st century woman on the other side of the world, possibly tap into whatever that was?

I hope. I dream. I write.

Best wishes,

Rowena

Rowena in Florence

Photographed at a monastry near Florence in 1992.

Letter From Botticelli

Dear Rowena,

Thank you very much for your letter.

Now, what was your question? Please excuse me. I’m feeling a bit foggy today and haven’t had to bother myself with earthly matters for a very long time. Indeed, much of your memory gets deleted once you enter the pearly gates. After all, you’re not supposed to be spending eternity regretting things on Earth when you’re in heaven!

Yet, nothing could erase those flames, and seeing those precious masterpieces burning up. A wolf in sheep’s clothing, we followed him like lambs to the slaughter house. Florence was magnificent…the jewel of the Renaissance.  She wasn’t perfect but, it wasn’t Sodom and Gomorrah. It wasn’t hell on Earth. Well, that is until he stepped in.

In my defense, Rowena, I would like to suggest that you can’t always control of your own strings. Not that you’re a puppet, but even an artist has to eat and to some extent, each of us has had to sell our soul. Serve it up on a platter. That’s just the way it is…or how it was.

Meanwhile, I’ve heard that they now hide artworks away during times of war and keep the world’s great masterpieces away from the battlefield. Protect what is more than just a reflection of humanity, a mirror, but also radiates the human spirit. As you might appreciate, art crosses language and cultural barriers and draws humans closer together. Well, that’s if we allow ourselves to be moved.

Anyway, I haven’t asked you if you paint? I’ve always been a great teacher. If you feel like popping back, I’d be happy to teach you.

Best wishes,

Botticelli.

 

21 thoughts on “B: Botticelli…A-Z Challenge.

  1. TanGental

    I saw that Botticelli at the Uffizi in November 1992 accompanied by a scurrying 2 year old. Utterly terrified he’d cross the electrified barrier and have the guards on us. It will always be a fleeting memory of size as much as skill as he wove in and out many legs. Art is consumed in many ways.

  2. Wolf of Words

    I love this concept of writing to artists long gone. It kind of grounds the look into the past. As a weird kid (and a fan of Where’s Waldo), I always loved Botticelli’s The Map of Hell. Like all of his paintings, it is so creative and full of interesting little details.

  3. karen@profoundjourney.com

    Here’s another ‘b’ for you, Rowena. Brilliant. That’s my one-word summation of today’s letters. How right you are that it is much more difficult to ask one question than many. I think you asked the right question and Botticelli gave you an honest answer – for his time although, I hope, maybe slightly less relevant to ours.

  4. Cathy Kennedy

    Rowena,

    Thank you for visiting yesterday. I’m playing catch up this morning before I feel too overwhelmed as the day goes on. I have many things to get down beside blogging and can’t afford to allow myself to get further behind. Anyhow, I enjoyed your letter approach. It’s fun to imagine what it would be like to communicate with someone from the past with the response to your letter. Very creative and cool A2Z idea. Have a good day hoping around Blogosphere!

    Y’all are invited to visit my all-in-one mewsic, sparks, & a2z post on Curious as a Cathy! 😉

  5. Jacqui Murray

    I do like the letter. I must say, I like your discussion of where death puts us just as much. I agree–it’s a fungible line. Interesting that Sandra responded that much of her memories were deleted with death.

  6. Iain Kelly

    I had the pleasure of seeing ‘Venus’ in a gallery in Florence, along with other paintings by him. Certainly had an aura about it, perhaps just because it is such a famous image. The letters are a wonderful idea. Look forward to seeing who else you write too.

  7. Deborah Weber

    I think about Venus a lot, so the Botticelli’s beautiful image often comes to mind. But it’s his Primavera that really calls to me. Perhaps some day I’ll see it.

    How right you are that choosing one question is such a delicious challenge! But I’m glad you asked about the Bonfire. I knew about them, but I did not know it was rumored Botticelli may have participated. Life is so complicated, and it often seems unfair that sometimes only the distance of time gives us perspective we were unable to access in the moment.

    I find Botticelli’s response wonderful. A lovely reminder that when we let go of this life, we aren’t meant to carry regrets with us. But honoring what art IS inspires me into a fierceness I hadn’t really recognized in myself before.

    I rate today’s post B for beautiful. 🙂

  8. Pingback: C- Grace Cossington Smith (1892 – 1984): A-Z Challenge. | beyondtheflow

  9. Retirement Reflections

    Hi, Rowena – I agree with your other commenters. This post is both ‘brilliant’ and ‘beautiful’. I visited the galleries in Florence in 1974, and the Louvre in 2011 …. so your posts so far have been sitrring up very wonderful memories! I look forward to reading more.

  10. Rowena Post author

    Thank you very much. I don’t think you can ever forget the awe of seeing these masterpieces in person. Very different to seeing them in a book or online. I think a few gallery trips are coming up where I can at least see Australian works. The Grace Cossington Gallery is about an hour away. I can’t wait to go.

  11. Pingback: Letters to Dead Artists Weekly Round-Up… A-Z Challenge. | beyondtheflow

  12. Colette B

    Interesting questions you asked of Botticelli. It’s impossible not to admire his skill as a painter, i don’t think I’ve ever seen any for real, only in books.I’ll have to try and catch up here quicker, I’ll look forward to reading the next post later in the day.

  13. Pingback: A-Z Weekly Round up…Letters to Dead Artists. | beyondtheflow

  14. Pingback: Letters to Dead Artists – Weekly Round Up…A-Z Challenge | beyondtheflow

  15. Pingback: Reflections- Letters to Dead Artists…A-Z Challenge 2018. | Beyond the Flow

  16. Rowena Post author

    Thanks very much, Cathy. I know what you mean about getting back to the real world, but I am trying to take this as far as I can now so I am only digging in deeper now. The editing process begins. Good luck with it all.
    Best wishes,
    Rowena

  17. Rowena Post author

    I just Googled the Map of Hell and is exquisitely detailed. I had seen it while I was on the research trail. It’s magnificent.
    Best wishes,
    Rowena

  18. Rowena Post author

    Thanks, Linda. Sorry it’s taken me so long to reply. Your comment slipped through the net. I posted a summary page today, which lists all the artists and I’ve also put a piece of music to each post.
    Best wishes,
    Rowena

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.